Upcycling thrifted holiday decor is an affordable and eco-friendly way to create festive, personalized decorations. By transforming second-hand items like ornaments, glassware, and frames, you can craft unique decor while reducing waste and supporting local thrift stores like City Thrift, which helps fund community programs. From spray-painting outdated figurines to turning old frames into card holders, the possibilities are endless with a little creativity and basic tools like glue, paint, and Mod Podge.
Key Takeaways:
- Why Upcycle? Save money, reduce waste, and design one-of-a-kind decor.
- Top Items to Thrift: Glassware, ornaments, frames, baskets, and unexpected finds like fabric or tart tins.
- DIY Ideas: Create glass trees, modernize ceramic figurines, or build rustic displays using ladders or crates.
- Tools You’ll Need: Spray paint, strong adhesives, and texturizing agents like baking soda or glitter.
- Community Impact: Shopping at thrift stores like City Thrift supports local missions while giving new life to old items.
With thrifted finds, you can decorate your home for the holidays without overspending or relying on mass-produced items.
Best Thrifted Holiday Items to Upcycle
Not every thrift store find screams “holiday magic” at first glance, but that’s part of the fun. With a little creativity, you can transform everyday items into festive treasures. When browsing City Thrift, focus on sturdy materials and unique shapes that can be reimagined into holiday decor. From vintage glass to quirky knick-knacks, the possibilities are endless.
Vintage Ornaments and Glassware
Glassware is a thrifter’s dream when it comes to upcycling. Clear pressed glass bowls, plates, and candlesticks can be stacked into cone shapes, creating what DIY enthusiasts call “glass Christmas trees.” Use a strong adhesive like E6000 or Gorilla Glue to secure the layers, and you’ll have a sparkling centerpiece. Glass vases can also double as floating candle holders – just add water, greenery, and battery-operated LED lights for a cozy holiday glow.
Even mismatched ceramic village houses or incomplete nativity sets can find new life. Marlise Kast-Myers, owner of Brick n Barn, explains:
“If we have a nativity scene with missing pieces, we wouldn’t be able to sell the set as is; however, the individual figures can always be turned into ornaments.”
A quick coat of white or metallic spray paint can modernize outdated pieces, giving them a sleek, festive look.
Frames, Baskets, and Trays
Everyday items like picture frames, baskets, and trays can bring unexpected charm to your holiday decor. Vintage frames, for example, can be repurposed into holiday gallery walls by backing them with old sheet music or postcards. Canvas frames are perfect as card holders – just stretch ribbon or twine across the opening and secure holiday cards with mini clothespins. Wooden or metal trays can become cookie platters for Santa with a little paint and decoupage.
Baskets and wooden crates also add a rustic touch. Use them as bases for Christmas trees, fill them with cozy blankets and pinecones, or stack them for tiered displays. Camille McMullin, a thrifting and DIY expert, shares her tip:
“Thrift stores are full of wreaths and while many are outdated, a quick removal of undesirable décor makes for a blank canvas.”
Even sparse or worn-out wreaths can be revived with fresh greenery and seasonal embellishments.
Unexpected Items for Holiday Accents
Sometimes, the most unconventional finds lead to the most creative decorations. Scrabble tiles glued to craft sticks can spell out festive words for personalized ornaments. Chair spindles transform into oversized rustic ornaments with a little paint and hardware. Tart tins? They can be decoupaged with holiday images or stacked into tiny metal trees. Even old books can be repurposed – accordion-fold the pages to create paper angels, or stack and paint the spines with holiday phrases like “O’ Holy Night.”
Don’t overlook fabric finds, either. Old plaid pajamas or cable-knit sweaters are perfect for crafting heart-shaped ornaments, stockings, or even tree skirts. Rolling pins, yardsticks, and Jenga blocks also offer interesting shapes and textures for rustic holiday displays. And the best part? Shopping at City Thrift supports City Union Mission‘s efforts in the Kansas City community, so your creativity has a meaningful impact.
Step-by-Step Upcycling Projects
Ornaments and Figurines
Give those outdated ceramic Santas and reindeer a fresh, modern twist with a little paint. Start by washing them with dish soap, then apply a primer if the surface is glossy. Spray paint works wonders for achieving a smooth, professional finish – try snow-white, navy blue, or metallic gold for a chic, updated look. For an extra touch of elegance, use gold gilding wax on raised details to make them pop.
Glass ornaments are another great canvas for creativity. With the baking soda paint method, you can create a trendy matte texture. Just mix baking soda into acrylic paint and brush it onto plastic or glass baubles to mimic a stone-like finish. Want something flashier? Cut old CDs into small, unique shapes and hot-glue them onto ornaments for a disco-ball effect. Or, try wrapping faux-pearl necklaces around ornaments, securing them with glue as you go, for a more refined look.
Even mismatched teacups can become miniature holiday scenes. Fill them with faux snow, bottlebrush trees, and tiny toy cars for a whimsical touch. If you have glass cloches, they’re even better – they’ll not only protect your delicate dioramas from curious hands but also add a vintage flair to your holiday decor.
DIY Holiday Displays
Once you’ve transformed individual pieces, it’s time to bring them together into cohesive displays. For example, thrifted books can become decorative accents. Paint their spines in matching colors, add festive phrases like “Merry & Bright” with stencils or vinyl lettering, and tie the stack with twine. Tuck in a sprig of faux greenery for a polished finish.
Tart tins can also be reimagined as wall art. Decoupage vintage holiday cards into the centers, then brush glue on the scalloped edges and dip them in Epsom salt for a frosted effect. Empty canvas frames make excellent holiday card holders – just string ribbon or twine across the frame and clip on cards with mini clothespins. For a bigger impact, take a large framed artwork, remove the glass, and coat the surface with black chalkboard spray paint. This creates a blank canvas for hand-drawn winter scenes.
Even thrifted trays can find new life as Santa cookie platters. Paint them in festive colors, line the surface with wrapping paper, and seal it all with Mod Podge for a durable, seasonal look.
Large-Scale Decor Projects
For larger decor, think outside the box – literally. An old wooden ladder leaning against a wall can be a charming way to display stockings or ornaments without taking up floor space. Large handled baskets can be transformed into rustic tree collars by simply removing the handle and bottom with wire cutters. If you’re tight on space, a bedspring mounted to the wall can serve as a vertical “tree“, perfect for hanging ornaments.
Want a show-stopping centerpiece? Stack thrifted glass bowls, plates, and saucers in a cone shape, securing each layer with strong adhesive like E6000 or Gorilla Glue. This creates a sparkling glass tree that beautifully reflects light. If you’re in Kansas City, City Thrift is a great spot to find affordable pressed glass pieces – $50 can get you an array of bowls, vases, and even small tables to anchor your display.
Metal tomato cages also make fantastic porch trees. Wrap them with evergreen branches or strips of fabric for a festive touch. And don’t overlook those ceramic village houses you see at thrift stores. A few coats of spray paint in a uniform color can completely transform them. Add some battery-operated fairy lights to any of these projects for a warm, glowing finish – no outlets required.
These ideas show how thrifted treasures can be turned into stunning decor, all while keeping the eco-conscious spirit of upcycling alive.
Tools and Materials for Upcycling
Having the right supplies can make all the difference when transforming thrifted holiday finds into something new. The good news? You don’t need a fancy craft setup or expensive tools – most of what you’ll need costs less than $15. The trick is knowing which tools work best for specific surfaces and how to get the most out of them.
Adhesives are essential for nearly every upcycling project. If you’re working with lightweight items like paper ornaments or ribbon garlands, hot glue is your go-to for quick and easy assembly. For heavier materials – like metal, wood, or glass – stronger adhesives like E6000 or Gorilla Glue are ideal for creating durable, lasting bonds. For decoupage projects, Mod Podge is a fantastic option. It not only adheres paper and fabric to various surfaces but also provides a smooth, protective finish.
Paint and finishes can completely change the look of outdated decor. Spray paint is a quick and effective way to cover ceramics or metal, with popular colors like gold, white, and black offering a modern touch. For smaller or more detailed projects, acrylic craft paints (such as Liquitex BASICS) give you precision and control. Want to create an antique gilded effect? Rub ‘n Buff is a great choice for adding a metallic finish to frames and figurines. DIY expert Holly Antoine suggests using a black spray paint base coat before applying gold Rub ‘n Buff on shiny surfaces. This trick helps the gold stand out and gives it a more authentic, antique feel.
Texturizing agents bring depth and interest to your projects without breaking the bank. For instance, mixing baking soda into acrylic paint creates a trendy, matte, stone-like texture – perfect for glass or plastic ornaments. If you want a frosted, wintry effect, sprinkle Epsom salt over wet glue on tins or glassware. And for a touch of sparkle, glitter works wonders, but don’t forget to seal it with a spray varnish to keep those sparkles in place all season long.
Comparison Table: Tools and Materials
| Tool/Material | Cost | Ease of Use | Durability | Best Use Case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spray Paint | $6–$12 per can | High | High | Large surfaces, ceramics, metal |
| Hot Glue | $5–$15 (gun + sticks) | High | Medium | Lightweight items, quick assembly |
| E6000/Gorilla Glue | $5–$10 per tube | Medium | Very High | Heavy items like metal accents, wood |
| Mod Podge | $5–$15 per jar | High | Medium | Decoupage, sealing paper and fabric |
| Chalk Paint | $15–$30 per jar | High | Medium | Distressed, farmhouse wood finishes |
| Glitter/Faux Snow | $3–$10 | Medium | Low | Adding sparkle requires a sealer |
| Rub ‘n Buff | $10–$20 | High | High | Ornate, antique gold finishes |
In October 2025, Holly Antoine showcased her creativity with thrift flips for holiday decor. She turned $1.00 vintage lamp shades into ornaments using Gorilla Glue and rustic bells, keeping the total cost under $7.00. She also upcycled $3.50 wall sconces into gilded candle holders by combining black spray paint with gold Rub ‘n Buff, spending less than $15.00 on the project.
Styling Your Upcycled Holiday Decor
Give your upcycled holiday treasures a polished, festive vibe by focusing on styling. Thrift stores like City Thrift offer plenty of affordable finds, letting you celebrate the season while supporting local initiatives.
Layering Textures and Colors
Blending textures and colors can make your decor feel more inviting. Start with soft materials like a thrifted plaid scarf or a lace tablecloth to create what Rachel from The Antiqued Journey describes as a “textural base” that anchors your setup. Then, layer in harder accents like brass candlesticks, glass cloches, or painted ceramic figurines for contrast.
Stick to a consistent color palette – three to five shades work well – and carry it across different areas. For example, if you’ve spray-painted mismatched ornaments in matte white and gold, use those same tones for your table settings, mantel displays, and tree decorations. Adding natural elements like pinecones or greenery can tie everything together. For an extra touch of harmony, use the same ribbon style – whether velvet or gingham – on wreaths, garlands, and gifts. These simple strategies can make thrifted pieces from varying eras and styles feel like they were always meant to go together.
By layering textures and keeping your color scheme cohesive, you can effortlessly blend vintage charm with modern holiday aesthetics.
Mixing Vintage and Modern Elements
To add depth and character, mix vintage finds with contemporary pieces. Start with a neutral foundation – Anna, founder of Sky Lark House, recommends limiting your palette to three to five colors to create harmony between old and new. For example, a neutral base accented with gold and silver allows an aged patina mirror to complement sleek mercury glass candles (around $15 each). The mirror’s weathered surface reflects the candlelight, creating a timeless, layered effect.
“By mixing vintage and new items, you can create holiday décor that is both stylish and personal.” – Anna, Founder, Sky Lark House
Pair modern artificial trees or faux stems with antique vessels like ironstone pitchers, trophy cups, or galvanized buckets. This combination gives contemporary items a touch of character while highlighting the beauty of your thrifted finds.
You can also update outdated pieces with a modern twist. For instance, spray-paint ceramic Santas or reindeer in trendy solid colors like matte white, navy blue, or gold. This small change transforms them into sophisticated accents that fit seamlessly with newer decor. On your tree, mix these refreshed ornaments with affordable modern replicas (like $3 cardboard house ornaments or tinsel stars) to achieve a full, festive look without breaking the bank.
| Vintage Element | Modern Pairing Idea | Styling Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Ironstone Pitcher | Gold/Silver Faux Stems | Rustic meets Glam |
| Vintage Mirror | Mercury Glass Candles | Enhanced light and patina |
| Antique Postcards | Modern Minimalist Wreath | Nostalgic focal point |
| Thrifted Scarf | Modern Artificial Tree | Textured, cozy base |
| Brass Candlesticks | Colorful Taper Candles | Eclectic and vibrant |
Celebrate the Holidays with Upcycled Decor
Upcycled decor offers a perfect blend of creativity, savings, and sustainability, making it an excellent choice for the holiday season. While the average American spends between $269 and $375 on holiday decorations, opting for thrifted items can slash that cost to just 10–20% of retail prices. Beyond saving money, this choice helps reduce waste and gives new life to items that might otherwise end up in landfills.
What makes upcycled decor truly special is the personal touch it brings. Unlike mass-produced decorations, thrifted and repurposed pieces carry a sense of history and craftsmanship that can transform your home into something truly unique. These items not only reflect your personal style but also embody your values, creating a space filled with character and meaning.
“Vintage decor allows you to focus on the true meaning of the holiday season, rather than getting caught up in the commercialism.” – Jennifer Howard, Owner/Creator, Cottage On Bunker Hill
Choosing upcycled decor also supports your local community. Shopping at City Thrift, for example, gives you access to a constantly changing selection of clothing, furniture, toys, and household items – perfect for your next DIY project. Plus, every purchase directly supports City Union Mission’s efforts to provide meals, shelter, and vital community programs to those in need in Kansas City, a mission they’ve upheld since 1924. By shopping at City Thrift, you’re not just creating beautiful holiday decor; you’re contributing to a greater cause.
Kick off your upcycling journey today and craft holiday magic that’s as affordable as it is meaningful. Visit your local City Thrift store to uncover vintage ornaments, glassware, and other treasures just waiting to be transformed into something extraordinary.
FAQs
How do I clean thrifted decor before painting?
Before painting thrifted decor, start by cleaning it thoroughly using a gentle approach. A mix of soap and water works well to remove dust and grime. For larger items, wipe them down with a soapy rag and rinse them outside. For delicate or vintage pieces, skip harsh chemicals and instead use a soft brush to carefully clean away dirt. Make sure the surface is completely dry before you begin painting to ensure smooth and lasting results.
What glue works best for glass or heavy items?
Gorilla Super Glue with Brush & Nozzle Applicator is an excellent option for bonding glass or heavier items. It delivers a dependable, strong hold, making it effective for these types of surfaces. To achieve the best results, make sure the surfaces are thoroughly clean and dry before applying the glue.
How can I make thrifted pieces look cohesive?
To bring together thrifted pieces seamlessly, start by selecting a unifying theme or color palette. Think metallics, crisp whites, or classic holiday shades like red and green. Stick to similar textures or styles – vintage or rustic elements work well together. You can also use DIY techniques, such as painting or distressing items in coordinating colors, to tie everything together. Arranging similar items in groups or displays adds to the cohesive, intentional feel while showcasing your personal flair.
